Image credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
San Francisco Giants trade 2B Luis Arraez and RHP Caleb Kilian to Philadelphia Phillies for RHP Ramon Marquez and RHP Marty Gair.
When I wrote a couple weeks ago that this was shaping up to be a weird deadline, I had things in mind like the Blue Jays entering sell mode but still buying Jose Soriano’s services at the cost of one of their top prospects, or the contending White Sox shipping out their mercurial and sometimes-closer Seranthony Domínguez. Luis Arraez, though? Arraez always presented the kind of straightforward deal we’re used to at a deadline. The Giants have been going nowhere fast for years now, and that hasn’t changed despite substantial investment into the lineup. Arraez’s one-year deal and revived defense at second base made him eminently moveable, and the Phillies, especially under Dave Dombrowski, are among the more logical landing spots as contenders who are looking to lengthen their lineup.
So conceptually there’s nothing weird about this trade. But Philadelphia has announced that Arraez will play second base for them, which is both unsurprising and raises a number of questions about their defensive alignment. If Bryson Stott isn’t playing second base…where is he playing? Whatever answer you give (short or third) will have a number of knock-on effects: If he goes to third, it means Alec Bohm is either off the team or crossing the diamond to first, and bumping Bryce Harper back to corner outfield. If he goes to short, it means Trea Turner is shifted to center field, a place he hasn’t occupied but for 45 games back in 2016. If you want to get reductive about it, Arraez’s acquisition either looses Bohm from the roster or kicks a one-time National to the outfield grass.
