Newcastle are absolutely right to chase Carl Rushworth as an alternative to James Trafford, with the Magpies now holding talks over both men to potentially see which is the most viable deal for Eddie Howe‘s side.
Howe has spent long enough trying to solve the club’s goalkeeping problem, and these are two of England’s most promising options.
Trafford’s pedigree is already well known, while Rushworth arrives after an outstanding Championship campaign that produced 17 clean sheets in 46 league games and a place in the division’s Team of the Year.
The 25-year-old enjoyed a truly superb loan spell with Coventry last season, helping Frank Lampard’s side secure promotion while establishing himself as one of the Championship’s standout performers.
His calm distribution, command of the penalty area and consistency earned widespread praise, with Brighton rejecting multiple permanent offers as they considered his own future at the Amex.
Trafford, meanwhile, has remained Newcastle’s dream target for much longer.
The England international has been on the club’s radar across several transfer windows and remains highly regarded despite limited opportunities since returning to City.
The Man City keeper found himself second fiddle behind Gianluigi Donnarumma, but his spell at Burnley showed plenty of promise, so much so that Thomas Tuchel brought him to the World Cup as an understudy.
|
Football FanCast’s Verdict |
|
|---|---|
|
Credibility |
This story comes from Simon Jones, who has covered transfers for the Daily Mail for many years and is well connected across the Premier League. While not every exclusive lands, his reporting is regularly echoed by other established journalists. This latest update also aligns with Newcastle’s widely reported search for a new first-choice goalkeeper. |
|
Finances |
Rushworth’s valuation has risen sharply after Brighton rejected bids exceeding £20 million from Coventry earlier this summer, while Trafford would also command a significant fee after City’s investment. Newcastle therefore appear to be weighing two expensive but long-term solutions rather than pursuing a short-term, lower-cost alternative. |
|
Insight |
Rushworth has developed into a composed modern goalkeeper who excels with the ball at his feet and rarely looks flustered under pressure. Trafford possesses similar qualities but brings additional Premier League experience. Both are comfortable sweeping behind a high defensive line, making either an excellent stylistic fit for Howe. |
|
Impact |
Signing either goalkeeper would represent a major step for Newcastle. Greater reliability between the stricks would strengthen the defence, improve build-up play and increase competition throughout the squad. Over time, the right appointment could become one of the club’s most influential signings. |
Both fit Newcastle’s long-term vision of signing players entering their prime rather than those approaching the end of it.
The Magpies’ search for a new number one now appears to be intensifying.
Newcastle in talks over signing Carl Rushworth alongside James Trafford
According to Daily Mail journalist Simon Jones, Newcastle have added Brighton goalkeeper Carl Rushworth to their shortlist and are already in talks over a possible deal.
However, discussions with City regarding Trafford are continuing at the same time, suggesting Howe is determined to strengthen the position before the new season begins.
The interest in Rushworth and Trafford is hardly surprising.
Newcastle clearly believe both men have the attributes to become Premier League leading goalkeepers, but competition for their signature will be there.
That being said, pursuing both players gives Newcastle flexibility.
You scored
out of 20
If City continue to resist selling Trafford or the financial package becomes too expensive, Rushworth represents an outstanding alternative.
Goalkeeper has been identified as an area requiring improvement, particularly with Nick Pope’s future attracting speculation and Newcastle looking to build a side capable of challenging consistently at the top end of the Premier League.
